Parental Alienation in Court: Dealing with Judicial Anxiety

8/31/2017

Increasingly, even as we become better and being clearer and more precise as to what will help remedy a Parental Alienation court case, it appears to be the case that Judges often hesitate to follow such recommendations.
Very often, the targeted parent will have been accused falsely of being in some way dangerous, unstable or otherwise suspect as a parent. Since the court should always carefully examine any potential danger that such a parent might represent, it should then also recognize that the fact remains that parents are falsely accused of tendencies and acts that are not them.

In cases such as these, where such possibility of danger has been carefully vetted and found to be absent, the court should then act accordingly. Sadly, we find that not to be the case very frequently. I believe that a key reason for this is that the second part of the equation involving false allegations is seldom executed.

What needs to happen – and this is the frequently missing piece – is for the case presentation to say essentially, “not only is this parent not guilty of what they have been accused of being, but what is true is that the other parent has affirmatively attempted to defraud the court” by accusing them as being so.

When this argument is effectively and strongly made, the court’s attention shifts from the targeted parent onto the alienating parent. ​

It is at this point that the lightbulb of insight goes on for the judge and they begin to rule in a more corrective fashion. Absent this step, it appears to me that the judge is left with a lingering suspicion regarding the targeted parent.

Therefore, Parental Alienation case presentation must bring the attention back to the alienating parent in a robust fashion. For reasons that I cannot clearly delineate, many attorney’s appear to be uncomfortable with this last step, often citing that they want to remain as the “reasonable one”. I believe that this is very often a serious error.

Learn to counter, deflect, and defend against criticisms and misinformation about Parental Alienation and Parental Alienation Syndrome by enrolling in the on demand online workshop, “Litigating Family Law Cases with Parental Alienation

Gerelateerde Artikelen